Commentary: Metallica Redefining 'Sell-Out'
Napster has arguably been a pain in the piggy banks of many commercial artists out there complaining of low record sales and meager royalty checks, but recently artists, specifically Metallica, have made some new enemies; the schools. That's right folks, Metallica has decided that by suing higher education institutions and Napster itself, it will stop their user base/fans from "pirating" their works.
It’s questionable that such an artist as Puffy Combs, who makes a living off remixing other artists' work, has the moral stature to cry wolf when he sees his work being traded on Napster, or any other media sharing device out there on the market. If anything, it probably promotes his music more than it "rips it off" as the artists like to call it. Yet when a huge commercial rock monster like Metallica cries wolf, people listen.
As announced on BetaNews, earlier today Metallica filed suit in U.S. District Court for the Central District of California against Napster, three educational institutions, and 20 fans for unauthorized distribution of music. The suit alleges that by enabling music piracy to occur, the defendants have committed copyright infringement. Specifically named thus far are Yale University, the University of Southern California, and Indiana University.
Despite being known for supporting fans' bootlegging of their live performances, Metallica's Lars Ulrich said in a statement, "[It's] sickening to know that our art is being traded like a commodity rather than the art that it is." Ulrich once was "amused" at the release of a bootleg album, until he found out the tape was a doctored recording touted as live. It’s funny how Lars deems it "sickening to know that our art is being traded like a commodity" when the very "art" he is referring to is being traded like a commodity in the stores.
As far as piracy goes, I have to do nothing but whole-heartedly agree with Metallica. Piracy is personally disgusting to me. If you want to download music off the Internet, download some good indie rock that far surpasses the quality of corporate rock dinosaurs, such as Metallica, that are jaded by the fact that good music can now be distributed freely by indie labels much more effectively then their corporate predecessors. If you have the least bit of Interest in a band, no matter who they are, you should find some way to support them. Buy their albums, t-shirts, concert tickets. If you want to listen to free music go to listen.com or mp3.com.
The key factor in this whole lawsuit is the question of what Metallica deems as "fair use." Perfectly stated in a quote from an anonymous person on the Napster message forum, "Oh man. Don’t they understand? Personally, I discovered Metallica while using Napster and I have bought 5 of their albums since, which amounts up to quite a lot of money. I'm sure this works with other people the same way."
Suing universities and the company itself will not put a dent in this battle. Education and awareness will. In the end, it’s the consumer who needs to be dealt with and taught how to handle MP3 files, as well as programs like Napster responsibly. I highly question Metallica’s motives for suing the institutions of higher education. It is quite an insult that they would rather sue the very schools that are cracking down on piracy rather than dealing with the pirates themselves. SAUC is looking into this, as well as working around the clock to keep you up to date on the latest news. Chuck D, if you are out there, give us a buzz.